The article under review is titled “Global governance by goal-setting: the novel approach of the UN Sustainable Development Goals,” co-authored by Frank Biermanna, Norichika Kanieb, and Rakhyun E. Kim. The article revolves around the idea of global governance through goal setting and delves into various aspects of SGDs, their mechanisms of governance, challenges being faced regarding their implementation, and the need for adaptation to national circumstances.
A thorough understanding of the subject matter has been demonstrated, supported by insights drawn from multi-year research efforts and international workshops. The structure of the article is well-organized, which allows readers to follow the discussion easily. Each section is dedicated to exploring different aspects of SGDs that provide a nuanced understanding of their implications for global governance.
The article identifies several challenges in implementing SGDs that include the need for concrete targets, effective arrangements of global governance, mobilization of resources, adaptation to national circumstances, and policy integration. To strengthen the global governance arrangements, there is a need for the mobilization of resources from both the public and private sectors.
The article underscores the importance of clear indicators and effective translation between global and national aspirations by recognizing the need for universal application of SGDs while adapting them according to national contexts. Effective implementation requires an integrated approach to address complex interlinkages between different goals and sectors by avoiding negative trade-offs and fostering positive synergies.
While the article provides a thorough analysis of the SGDs, it could benefit from greater engagement with opposing viewpoints or critiques. The authors acknowledge some challenges associated with SGD, but a more nuanced discussion of potential criticisms or limitations would enrich the analysis. Moreover, the article could explore the implications of governance through goals in more depth.
The writing style of the author is very clear, precise, and scholarly, and the language used is accessible yet authoritative, which makes complex concepts understandable to a wide audience. The writing style is very well suited to the subject matter.
Overall, the article offers valuable insights. It contributes to our understanding of global efforts towards sustainability and the role of goal-setting in shaping global governance agendas.
The writer is a student of “Government and Public Policy” at “National Defence University” and a member of PYDIR.